Plagued by a hidden childhood trauma that is destroying his life, an obsessive-compulsive MMA fighter moves to Fire Island and pretends to be gay in order to buy the house of his dreams and exorcise his demons.
Unfortunately the movie I'm Not Gay : A Musical is not yet available on Disney Plus.
| Directing | Scott L. Semer | Director |
| Writing | Scott L. Semer | Writer |
| Crew | Luca Fantini | Cinematography |
| Sound | Benjamin Velez | Music |
| Production | Carrie Ormond | Producer |
| Crew | Stacey Tookey | Choreographer |
| Art | Charlie Corcoran | Production Design |
| Editing | Lucas Sabean | Editor |
