One Christmas Eve, Santa makes a big mistake. He leaves a little girl's doll and stuffed cat at the house of the little boy down the street, and the boy's soldiers at the girl's house. The toys come to life and sort it all out, but not before getting into a little mischief. Narrated by Mel Torme, famous singer of The Christmas Song -"Chestnuts roasting by an open fire..."
Unfortunately the movie Story of the Christmas Toys is not yet available on Disney Plus.
| Writing | Lee Hartman | Writer |
| Directing | Lee Hartman | Director |
| Visual Effects | Lee Hartman | Animation |
| Production | Jack D'Amico | Executive Producer |
| Sound | Art Quinn | Music |
| Sound | Phil Lenz | Audio Post Coordinator |
| Art | Jerry Forney | Background Designer |
| Crew | Joe D'Amico | Post-Production Manager |
| Sound | Sandy Reinert | Music |
| Sound | Rick Purcell | Music |
| Production | Suzanne McClure | Production Assistant |
| Editing | Pat Raffaele | Editor |
